"Poor" is a term that relates to one's expectations, especially in your case if what I've read is any indication. There is no standardized scale in entertainment. Whether or not warnings prior to hazards are merited, and to what degree, is up to personal preference.
Of course life is subjective and people are entitled to their opinions. The only absolute things in life are probably the facts.
Let's bring up the forced gameover situation yet again. I can say it's cheap and unfair. On the other hand, I could say it adds "replay value." Obviously, I believe the former and, from past experiences (i.e. X~X5), think it should have been excluded from the game. Don't agree with me and think my thought process is flawed? Fine, but we'll end it with that.
Shadow X again forsakes default abilities, that being the air-dash. It's not something to give up so recklessly.
You were a stickler about expecting X5-to-X6 similarities, so I'll give you one: Shadow is X6's equivalent to Gaia Armor. Gaia Armor hampered your default abilities by slowing your dash speed, which made Zero Virus Stage 1 very nearly impossible, and far more tedious than I care to repeat despite my love of Gaia. Shadow, likewise, does the same in its lacking an air-dash, a feature which X6 utilizes far more than X5 did. It's the tradeoff for your spike immunity and insane power (Gaia's buster raped bosses, if you recall). However, unlike Gaia, Shadow doesn't cancel Power-Up Parts, so you can compensate. An option which X5 did not provide.
Shadow is a trade-off in lacking abilities you started the game with. Such should not be taken recklessly.
Not exactly. Shadow is partially handicapped, yes, but it's different from Unarmored X in that it has benefits. Unlike Unarmored X, which is solely for challenge, Shadow is offered as a differing play style.
As far as I am concerned Shadow Armor is understood as partially handicapped for reasons I described above, therefore I did not consider Gate's Lab 2 relevant to discussions of a run which you specifically described as not handicapped. Your last post wasn't very specific in which part of the game you were complaining about. You "moved past" unarmored X complaints but the specific point at which you did so was not clear to me.
Sorry for being unclear then.