I don't read comics Ben, so at least from just looking at them I'd have to strongly disagree (feet claws could be interesting 
). How about you try to convince why Daken would be better? I seriously don't know much about either of the two, so I'd kinda appreciate the comparison.
While both are basically two different answers on how to do another take on the "Wolverine" character, I just always thought Daken was more interesting, by virtue of the fact that he's an amoral, cavalier antithesis to Logan. On the other hand, X-23 just basically came off to me as the "Sakura" to Wolverine's "Ryu", in that she does a lot to repeat a number of the same things of her predecessor, just in a different context.
Perhaps things have changed since I last "checked in", but that's what I got.
Any way, nice to see Tron (re)-confirmed, I suppose. I wonder if that's a different voice actor from before...