EA - "I HAVE BROUGHT PEACE, FREEDOM, JUSTICE, AND SECURITY....TO MY NEW EMPIRE!"
Gamers: YOUR new Empire?
EA: DON'T MAKE ME KILL YOU (or rather, another of your favorite franchises)!
Gamers: EA, our allegiance is to single-player experiences! To actual story-telling!
EA: If you're not with me....then you're my enemy!
Gamers: ...Only EA deals in absolutes. We will do what we must. *tries to pass over for other games*
EA: YOU WILL TRY....!
*flips out*
EA: FLIPPY, FLIPPY....LAVALAVALAVALAVALAVALAVA!!!! ...AHHHHH!!!!
(if you don't know what I'm talking about, well, then...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tb9BKEy8oEY&feature=related)
Oh, I agree with you that the Jedi Outcast/Academy games were much better than TFU. I liked the story for TFU though. I thought it was somewhat interesting. I prefer that battle engine style as well, over TFU.
My only thing is, why do they feel like we needed that chapter in the Star Wars storyline? The Clone Wars, Order 66 and all that stuff that came with it? I think we've had enough of that. It's only doing more to "cheapen" the storyline, the more stuff they try to add-on. Can we finally move on?
I mean, sure, currently, the EU in the books has started going down the crapper, as well, but before that, there was some good stuff. Plenty of things that I think could have been used as the source of great games. For example, if they REALLY wanted something from the "Sith" perspective, why not take us back to Darth Bane and the two books he inspired? That was the stuff of greatness.
Or, take a few cues from BioWare/RavenSoft and try and carve out their own niche in the mythos. Whatever. It's just starting to get to the point where, the more they do with anything relating to the two original trilogies, the worse it gets. And that "Legacy" comic series had such great potential too...
I don't think that BioWare wants to make KOTOR3. Why? They simply didn't make KOTOR2. To them, they lost the ability to make any more regular KOTOR games due to the crapfest that was KOTOR2. Granted, I enjoyed some of the features in KOTOR2. The real Jedi Robes and the ability to customize everything were nice; however, the story sucked and was literally unfinished when they released it. It's buggy and a lot of the times these bugs get fairly annoying. Even in the TOR's synopsis, it doesn't even acknowledge the events in KOTOR2. Then again, TOR takes place like 300 years after KOTOR.
KOTOR 2 was the more victim of Lucasarts meddling, rather than any real wrong-doing on Obsidian's part. Obsidian needed more time, which LA wasn't willing to give (because they wanted to release the game in time for the holidays years ago).
When that "as it should've been" epic-patch that fans are working is finished, I say, go give that game a go again. It may do more to give the notion that Obsidian, nor their KOTOR2, was given a fair shake.
But in any case, if they feel like KOTOR has been "spoiled" a bit, I don't see why that should make much a difference. Take the story to another tangent. Or hell, everything that they're doing for TOR is basically what could have been a feasible arc for a "KOTOR" continuation, Revan or no.
But the simple truth is, BioWare has seemingly been waiting for the right opportunity to make a MMO, and they wanted Star Wars to be their "hook". Boo on them. But at least, Mass Effect 2 and Dragon Age will hopefully tide me off, and fill that void...