Watched my brother replay Journey. That game never ceases to give me feels. The music and atmosphere is [tornado fang]ing perfect; not an exaggeration. I kinda felt like a kid again, watching the magic unfold.
The thing is, it's less of a game, and more so a visual and emotional experience that happens to be interactive.
I really can't think of many other games that had such a strong impact on me. I can understand some of the criticism it gets, though, as it's not a video game in the traditional sense.
On another note, Dexter is indeed getting stale now. I'll try to finish up this season, and see if the rest are worth my time.