Bitching about a game not being what it's not even trying to be is not something that makes a lot of sense to me. Same applies to offline Brawl discussions.
See, I wasn't clear on what you meant by "identity". The whole game-specific-code-crap, not knowing what your friends are playing, and all? There's a club for complaining about that. It's called Everybody, they meet at the bar. The 3DS is taking steps to rectify that, though IMHO there is absolutely no reason they shouldn't have had their act together with the Wii.
Communication ain't Nintendo's forte, either. I've been as frustrated by that as anyone else and I haven't even played an X-Box Live game. You don't have to run XBL comparisons to see the problem, by any means. The simple feeling of being cut off from your fellow players when online versus sitting down for a good local multiplayer session is pretty self-evident. But those are complaints against basically the entire Nintendo WFC service, not of any particular game. In that sense, Brawl is superior to Kart in that you at least get some personality in your customizable taunts. But it is just that, customization, not communication.
Crash, I haven't played. Sonic is fun, though the courses seem somewhat less interesting and less well-marked. But the balance is better, gotta give it that.
Yep, most of the reasons I hate "tournament players", is because every single game has to be perfectly balanced and amazingly competitive. Jesus Christ, Melee was accidentally competitive. Just let it go, guys.
And I know. But you know me, I like to complain. And the 3DS isn't taking [parasitic bomb]. Making only one code required instead of one per game isn't taking steps, it's just streamlining and making easier a feature which should have never been there in the first place. Nintendo only does this out of children safety, but what they don't understand is that all companies deal with this crap, and they wouldn't lose their family-friendly image by allowing something which would vastly increase their product quality. Then again, they're Nintendo. If they're making money, they don't give a [parasitic bomb] about raising the bar. And taunting is nothing, since Mario Kart essencially provides you with Leaderboards and other options that are common in games nowadays. The game essencially marked an attempt by Nintendo to do things right. Thing is, when you're painting with poop, there's not much else to go but brown.
Also, about Crash, you should really try it sometime, it's (don't kill me, crazy people) superior to MK64, in alot of ways. On All-Star Racing, I actually like the tracks better, because of the big airs you can pull, and how drifting is actually an in-game mechanic, easy to pull out and constantly used, instead of just the spark thing people overuse for snaking.