Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Zan

Pages: 1 ... 36 37 [38] 39 40 ... 79
926
ZX / Re: ZX Cameos
« on: January 09, 2010, 02:17:20 PM »
Quote
Are you sure you're not confusing theories, Zan?

No, there have been a gazillion newbies who came in after Z4 and went exclaiming: I think the Guardians died in Omega's explosion! I honestly can't believe you don't remember this. We ironically shot down that theory time and time again.

The theory of them being hit by Ragnarok was never ever proposed. Probably due to their location in Vile's Incident.

Quote
that indicates that no further information is needed

Like no further information was needed to understand Zero becoming Omega? As we know it, the Rockman series has a bad reputation with providing the relevant information within the game that it is needed, often obtaining said info by interview and sourcebooks.

Quote
except for Zero's own survival, which works against it.

Zero's own survival demanded the Mother Elf's interference it would seem, bringing him back to the resistance base, unconscious. Why is Zero unconscious? The game gives us no reason for Zero to be, yet he is. Now considering that that the Mother Elf is clearly smitten with Zero and thus occupied with solely him, and that X lacks the power to pull off the same trick, we leave the ultimate faith of the three Guardians quite mysterious. Whatever knocked Zero unconscious might have affected them somehow as well. Let us not forget that all three of them were on the verge of death to begin with.

Quote
Technically speaking, we don't even know that they're looking at Ragnarok.  The matter of context, that being it appears in Vile's Incident, is the only thing gearing it towards that event.  But once Aizu and co. have given the "fanservice; we just threw it in there" dismissal, even that can't be taken for granted.  They could be looking at a comet on their way to fight Omega, for all we know.

And that's pretty much what I'm trying to say here, we don't quite know what it is we're looking at there. From them being alive or dead, Ragnarok or a comet, or even that we're in the Substance World to begin with. We can only make educated guesses, since we have no context of that scene. Within Vile's Incident too, that image is a great oddity, there's no definite way a photograph of that scene could have been taken, Montagne could never have included it in his report, yet we see it clearly as part of it. It's clearly some image solely the fans can see, instead of an actual part of Vile's Incident's narrative.

About the only thing we can tell is that the scene could be most likely after Will4, as all the Four Guardians are united with each other and Master X. X and Phantom are the only ones confirmed as dead, somehow or other those previously unseen fancy coats came to be, and there's some falling star in the sky.

I don't know how anybody can place these event between Will4 and Retrospect1. But like the Ragnarok interpretation, it's all a matter of Inti rationalizing it adequately. You know, I could care less about the Guardians' actual moment of death, as long as there is some epic scene to be written there. It's just very sad that Inti hasn't seen it fit to write and present this scene.

Quote
False.  They said Operation Ragnarok, not Ragnarok the space station.  Big difference.

Point stands, he did not get help from the four Guardians, unless this help is as Cyber Elves. Either Inti's Four Guardian help idea is no longer valid, or they can indeed do things when they're dead. The latter would actually nicely pave the way to ZX.

927
Original / Re: Rockman 7/8 FC (Spoilers)
« on: January 09, 2010, 02:28:12 AM »
I'm honestly more concerned and appalled with their obsession toward ditching entire stages to uphold the retro formula.

928
Gaming / Re: Legend of Zelda - The official Zelda thread
« on: January 08, 2010, 09:48:33 PM »
Quote
WHEN ITS READY

Like Duke Nukem Forever?

929
X / Re: Sigma and the Jakob Project
« on: January 08, 2010, 06:49:19 PM »
A new world.

930
X / Re: Sigma and the Jakob Project
« on: January 08, 2010, 04:57:37 PM »
In other words, you two don't know either.

I personally feel the English game is less than clear. What with Sigma saying "all his doing" and then Lumine disagreeing by implicating it's only natural that Sigma's DNA was included. The Japanese script makes Sigma a bit more precise "from the very planning stages, the Jakob Project was all my doing."


931
X / Re: X8 virus refrences
« on: January 08, 2010, 02:48:13 AM »
*Waits for MarshmallowMan to jump in with lots of Japanese scribbles*

932
News and Announcements / Re: MMOCW and MMXOCW Summary and Review
« on: January 08, 2010, 02:19:42 AM »
Okay, that one, but I was mostly thinking of titles like Rockman Strategy and those Chinese edutainment games.

They're not Japanese enough.

933
X / Re: X8 virus refrences
« on: January 08, 2010, 12:16:42 AM »
No, it means the fan community's compiled knowledge is fanon.

934
X / Re: X8 virus refrences
« on: January 08, 2010, 12:05:02 AM »
Quote
No, He's the megaman fan community's compiled knowledge of Megaman gained sentience.

I am NOT equal to the MegaMan Knowledge Database, the very thought alone sickens me!

935
X / Re: X8 virus refrences
« on: January 07, 2010, 11:24:10 PM »
The intro stage is on Earth, but the intro cutscene with Dynamo is on Eurasia.

936
X / Re: X8 virus refrences
« on: January 07, 2010, 11:05:17 PM »
Zero never was in contact with the virus from the colony.

Zero experiences sudden boosts in power when it contact with the Sigma Virus and Zero Virus because they purify his systems. This is all explained in the two links I posted above.

937
News and Announcements / Re: MMOCW and MMXOCW Summary and Review
« on: January 07, 2010, 10:42:12 PM »
Quote
None of the other licensed games made it in

Rockman and Forte?

938
ZX / Re: ZX Cameos
« on: January 07, 2010, 03:59:21 PM »
Quote
Is that not only natural when you've just recovered from having the crap kicked out of you?

Harpuia is clearly pondering about what lies beyond the door and is willing to sacrifice his life. That is exactly what happened in Inti's current elaboration of the event. As such, there was indeed some hint toward the possibility. Yes, it does not establish what will happen, but a potential loss of their life was in the back of the developer's mind. Which is very much why in retrospect that moment was chosen.

Quote
The problem is, there was no reason to ask that question in the first place.

Their absence was the reason to ask that question. And indeed, that question WAS asked by fans, even having people come up with exactly that explosion to explain their idea. You're turning a blind eye to exactly everything that happened on forums such as this one, following the release of Z4.

The only reason we ever shot down that idea was a lack of effects in Vile's Incident, and a few vague ideas in the back of the developers minds. The unwritten ideas of developers should never constitute continuity, otherwise, Dark Elf's origins would have been retconned twice before the game was even released!

As for the effects..

Quote
The effects could easily be supplementary.

Of course, we have absolutely nothing to confirm that the effects absolutely have to be there on Leviathan. As a matter of fact, the inconsistency in the portrayal of Cyber Elves in this series was already brought forth twice. With what we know of these effects, their presence confirms a program life-form, but their absence does not confirm that something is a not a program life form. Indeed, Passy's effects were only shown on the moment she began using her power, and SvC does not have it at all. Whatever rationale we apply, the basic facts that their absence does not deny presence, can not be denied.

All Inti acknowledged in MMZOCW was the intent with which the image was made, and that they covered up that intend by acknowledging exactly the vagueness of aspects of that picture. We as fans should acknowledge exactly where that vagueness lies, and not cling so vehemently to our general distaste of the Guardians being killed in such a mundane manner.

If there is anything I blame Inti for, in regards to the Guardians' deaths, it's not that we were lead to think the opposite by their fickle developer's intend, it's more so that they absolutely failed to address the matter in subsequent releases. Instead of retcon, I call plothole. The explanation or enactment of the scene in question should have been somewhere in ZX, Drama Tracks, or otherwise, with preferred tie in to exactly that image in Vile's Incident. That it's only implicated at in an interview, is a clear issue of their presentation rather than them changing what's already been established.

Quote
"there is no way Zero can handle it [Operation Ragnarok] himself."

Except, Zero did, by omission of the Guardians and later by MMZOCW's accord. Unless, you take into account the possibility of them assisting without the need of their physical bodies, as X and Phantom have both done in the past.

Quote
We can't promise, but if there is a chance we'll make sure the Shitennou will take part in some way sometime for the users.
Quote
We'll enjoy when the day the acticity involving the Shitennou comes.

Rockman ZX. Which just comes to show that post-mortum activity of characters in this series has started becoming somewhat of a norm.

939
ZX / Re: ZX Cameos
« on: January 07, 2010, 02:57:20 AM »
Quote
I disagree wholeheartedly.  If you're saying that the account of their death in Z3 does not change what was established in continuity, then you could just as easily say the same of Elf Wars and Z1's continuity.  Nothing "in continuity" within Z1 is ignored, merely interpreted differently in light of what was revealed in the future.  Saying that Z2 changed the series while ZX did not is a double standard.

The difference is that Z1-2 is reinterpretation of game facts. Whereas Z4-ZX is reinterpretation of a context questionable image, and developers being unsure in interviews about what the hell is going on. Only the implications of the aforementioned context questionable image can be remotely considered as part of continuity.

The issue I have here, is that you're viewing Z4-ZX as equal to Z1-2 in the scale of retroactive continuity. The Guardians' death is relatively minor compared to what how things changed upon Z2's release.

Quote
Z3 left no such implications

Harpuia:  However the future hidden in the shadows beyond the door may turn out.  Wind drives away the fog, fire shows the road.  Water enriches the body, and shadow reflects oneself...  By the four heavens, we will become a light to guide the world!  Master X..  For humans' sake, we can continue to fight.  Even if it means our lives are exhausted as an offering for justice.

Quote
Not consistently.  Which begs the question of why Phantom is being differentiated from the others if they're all toast.

The others? Just Leviathan's uneven foot. Being entirely serious here, had Nakayama taken that image and 'altered' it to respect their deaths. How would these effects even be portrayed with Leviathan? I just don't see how it can cause the whole ankle and foot to vanish as with Phantom.

940
Fan Games / Re: Megaman: Redemption
« on: January 06, 2010, 08:19:30 PM »
You should definitely get rid of the whole Sage Trinity look.

941
X / Re: Sigma's Belial Form (X8)
« on: January 06, 2010, 06:01:45 PM »
The majestic void that is the long lost forum.

942
Fan Creations / Re: King Reaper! HE MAKES STUFF!
« on: January 06, 2010, 03:13:17 PM »
Quote
I wasn't quite sure how it was supposed to be shaded when viewed from the underside.

I wasn't quite sure either, but then I stumbled on his Super Adventure Rockman spritesheet.

943
ZX / Re: ZX Cameos
« on: January 06, 2010, 03:09:00 PM »
Quote
How often do you see any program life object appearing in the substance world that DOESN'T have some manner of energy effect around it?  The specifics of such may not be an exact science but there's pretty much always something.

Z1 Passy. SvC Cyber Elves. Furthermore, Phantom has never before been shown to materialize in this manner. If we start demanding that they all need those effects, we're making up whatever we want; there simply is no stated context to explain these effects, nor do we have an example to judge Leviathan's uneven foot positioning by. All that is left is our own assumption of what might seem obvious.

Quote
You look at sprite, art, and mugshot, and get three or four completely different looks.

All of these different forms have had art. Doesn't seem to be much of an inconsistency, rather, something deliberate.

Quote
But on the timeframe issue:  ZX.  Giro.  Dead in same game, and discolored from the waist down.

There's a key difference here, X does not appear in his projected robed form. The Vile's Incident image is not of the same type as Giro's projection. Also, both robed X and Giro were whole, even if static images.

Quote
It said "maybe" in regards to what they were doing, not that they "maybe" survived.

Playing devil's advocate here. Post mortum activities aren't exactly uncommon in this series. It is still our assumption that they are alive.

Quote
Barring the clear developer intent established there

Thing is, developer intent is not in question here. Inti's stance on the Guardians has always been one of circumstance. Can they make use them alive, or dead? As of Z4, there were still ideas floating about for their further use as living characters, which is only logical. Still, in the eventual need to make them dead, the Z3 ending was always made with that loophole in mind, as TELOS Harpuia lampshades. This is exactly what happened with ZX.

What is in question here, is if there is any facts of the continuity that have been altered. Whilst it is true that the creators made art with the idea that they're alive, but the resulting story context is left only to impression, not stated fact. As such, the answer is no, there is nothing to alter. Simply because their status is not confirmed in the continuity, only in out of continuity implications of developer intent.

In a similar but reverse scenario, before ZX there actually is no in-continuity statement of Zero's death in Z4. Thus they could at any given time have still decided to make him survive, even with the most convoluted of methods.

944
Fan Games / Re: Megaman: Redemption
« on: January 06, 2010, 12:34:50 AM »
=

Looking very Sage Trinity there, Mxues.

945
Fan Creations / Re: King Reaper! HE MAKES STUFF!
« on: January 06, 2010, 12:25:17 AM »
I'm not sure quite what the issue is. But I just feel like your overall shapes are... unrefined. Might also have something to do with your odd use of selective outlining for black, though.

I can't really explain it well in words, so I'll let this image do the talking:

946
Rockman Series / Re: Ancient Theories/Fanon
« on: January 05, 2010, 10:33:32 PM »
Quote
What happened, Iris went nuts out of grief that her brother had been killed by her lover is what happened. Not that her brain malfunctioned because of Colonel's death.

I believe you're forgetting something. She inserted Colonel's CPU, Ultimate Soldier and all that.

947
X / Re: X8 virus refrences
« on: January 05, 2010, 08:39:22 PM »
Quote
Im pretty sure Wily, the mysterious friend of Sigma's in X5, made the Colony virus.

It's not explained who made it. Only that Sigma used it on Eurasia, which caused the creation of the Zero Virus after a virus reaction, hence, Sigma made the Zero Virus. Even though we don't know who made the colony virus.

948
X / Re: X8 virus refrences
« on: January 05, 2010, 08:32:14 PM »
Same thing as both the Sigma Virus and Zero Virus, just programmed differently, with the objective of causing a virus reaction with the Sigma Virus.

949
X / Re: X8 virus refrences
« on: January 05, 2010, 08:14:15 PM »
Quote
So why exactly did mixing the Colonly virus (which was the same Sigma virus as the one on earth) with the Sigma Virus on Earth create the Zero Virus

The virus from the colony is NOT the same thing as the Sigma Virus. Also, because the colony virus was designed to do so. Sigma needed something better than the original Sigma Virus to achieve Zero's awakening. The mixing of the colony virus with Sigma Virus achieved that by creating the Zero Virus.

Quote
I thought that the Sigma virus was the Zero virus fused with Sigma's mind and half way diminished due to his advanced circuitry.

That is your misconception. Zero was the first infect with "Sigma Virus", having been born with it inside of him. The very same Sigma Virus that would eventually become one with Sigma after it had passed on to him from Zero.

http://www.themmnetwork.com/wiki/index.php?title=Sigma_Virus

Aside from the whole entry, I point you toward the first trivia:

Originally "Maverick Virus" was the term used to describe the computer virus that turns Reploids into Mavericks. Since the events of Mega Man X3 it is more commonly referred to as the "Sigma Virus" instead of the "Maverick Virus". From Mega Man X2 to Mega Man X4 resources alternate between "Sigma Virus","Maverick Virus" or describing it as a "Maverick-facilitating virus", a "virus that facilitates Maverick behavior", a "Maverick converting virus". From Mega Man X5 and onward, resources began to use "Sigma Virus" as the only name by which the virus is known, regardless of it being inappropriate in reference to the time of before Sigma's infection; since then the term "Maverick Virus" is seldom, if ever used.

950
Fan Creations / Re: King Reaper! HE MAKES STUFF!
« on: January 05, 2010, 07:33:43 PM »
I don't know why, but the line work on these "PU styled" stuff looks very very rough. Crashman's face is especially oddly shaped. Furthermore, with the new Rock sprite, you've strayed from the intended style quite a lot.

Pages: 1 ... 36 37 [38] 39 40 ... 79