It depends, MMAC was pretty horrible on one hand and X Collection wasn't too bad
Lol, what?
Anniversary collection was great, and it had both power battles games. one version also had a Megaman episode, while the other had an Inafune interview. The bonus music tracks were catchy too. and I really hadnt seen some of that Concept art.
Plus it had the little walking megaman game select, which was a fun touch.
now X collection...
first off, the game select music is in a set order, as no matter what you do, the first track on the list is X6's stage select, the bonuses are bad, seriously, I have the PS2 version, I really dont need to get arranged X3 music as a bonus when I already hear it in game. The hints are hints you can find ANYWHERE, the artwork once gain, was a nice touch, I hadnt seen all of it, but it isnt enough to redeem it. The game select was also pretty overly simplistic. Especially coming out of Anniversary collection, one expects more. Battle and Chase was cool, but they included the cut EU version, rather than localizing the original game, and they re-used part of X8's Capcom logo. It would have been perfectly fine without that part.
The title screen was pretty unnecessary as well, and while It was nice they made saving optional this time, i cant see why they had to replace the save menus on X4-6, which had its own.
and the last thing, select+start to return to the game select? that was a terrible combination. would it have killed them to make a little pop up menu like AC? Many a time did I accidentally press them both while in a stage. (especially since on the turbo controller I have, theyre closer together than on the regular one.
Oh dear- I went off on a tangent.
To try and get back on topic...
Im not too keen on this collection. Ill look over the box when it comes out, but most likely wont buy it.