I hate NGE, I hate FLCL, I like GURREN LAGANN, I so-so like PSG (mostly because of Demon Sisters and Garter).
As for this show... I've seen some of it on YT, because I didn't want to risk downloading it and then being disappointed... yeah, it was a wise move.
Somehow a sorta kinda grimdark retarded loli moe-blob show about magical girls... does not appeal to me. Which says something when I still like Sailor Moon and even enjoy Heartcatch Precure. Where the last one isn't grimdark (unlike Sailor Moon, which at times is), I find myself enjoying its great, "cute" and colorful cast of characters more than what Madoka throws at me.
Dunno, maybe grimdark magikal lolis aren't my thing... but I REALLY don't see the appeal of this show. I'll even go as far as to say it's [parasitic bomb].
It kinda seems to me that from now on, this will become "baby's first anime", dethroning Elfen Lied from this position.